GOALS.md

Project Name

aiConstitution

Mission

Turn the four-file personal AI Constitution prose stack (Constitution.md, Common.md, Code.md, Writing.md) into a portable, onboardable, self-repairing product — a Go CLI plus a Bubble Tea TUI plus a public methodology site — so that anyone, not only the original author, can install it, run a guided interview, and be governed by a personalized constitution within thirty minutes.

The system is designed to be deterministic where it can be (file operations, schema validation, sync, restore, doctor), model-mediated only where judgment is required (drafting amendment prose, proposing hook shapes), and always auditable — every override, every violation, every focus change leaves a permanent record the user can read.

See SPEC.md for the authoritative implementation specification (currently draft v0.8). This file is the goals layer that governs which decisions are in scope.

Principles

• Deterministic — same input produces the same output. The TUI, the resolver, the sync, the restore, the doctor: all reproducible, all scriptable. The model is used for prose, never for state.
• Auditable — every override, violation, focus change, and upstream contribution leaves a typed record. The audit trail is local-only and is never synced raw.
• Reproducible — atom registries (brand-atoms.com, persona-atoms.com, profile-atoms.com, skill-atoms.com) are versioned and content-hashed; a profile pinning coder@1.2.0 produces identical context across machines, sessions, and time.
• Onboardable — a literate adult who has never seen the prose stack can complete ai setup in under thirty minutes and end with a working personalized constitution.
• Strengthen, never weaken — every new surface inherits from the four canonical files. Lower-tier files MAY strengthen rules; they MUST NOT relax them. No new surface bypasses an existing hook or audit gate.
• Honest about defense-in-depth — the wrapper facade (~/.ai/bin/git, gh, etc.) is a defense-in-depth measure, not a security control. The spec is explicit about this; the wrapper’s first-run message says so.

Core Goals (G1–G7)

Non-Goals

• Not a multi-tenant SaaS. Each user’s ~/.ai/ is theirs. There is no shared identity service, no central registry of constitutions, no cross-user features. Sync targets are user-owned (private GitHub, GitLab, S3-compatible bucket, etc.).
• Not a replacement for the prose files. Constitution.md and the three companion files remain authoritative. The TUI generates them and the review loop amends them — neither replaces them.
• Not a model wrapper. This is the configuration plane around whatever agent the user already runs (Claude Code, Copilot CLI, Cursor, Codex).
• Not a secrets store. Per Common.md §4, secrets live in OS keychains, vaults, or env files. The system MUST NOT add a new place where they could land.
• Not exclusive mode-switching. ai mode --switch is honored as a CLI surface, but the underlying architecture activates personas additively rather than swapping domain files. See SPEC.md §7.

Anti-Goals (explicit)

• A wizard that fabricates rules.
• A sync that ships raw interaction logs (audit/interactions/*.jsonl is local-only per Common.md §5.2).
• A “doctor” that silently rewrites the user’s prose.
• An auto-update that silently re-wires hooks. Every migration step is shown and approved per item, except where the user has explicitly enabled update.autoMigrateApprove in settings.toml.

Out-of-Scope (this repo only)

This repository ships the CLI, the TUI, the hook library, the spec, and the public methodology site (aiConstitution.convergent-systems.co). The following are sibling projects that this repo references but does not contain:

• brand-atoms.com — W3C design tokens. Repo: convergent-systems-co/branding-library (existing).
• persona-atoms.com — agentic + reviewer persona atoms. Repo: convergent-systems-co/persona-atoms (in-progress).
• profile-atoms.com — profile composition atoms. Repo: convergent-systems-co/profile-atoms (in-progress).
• skill-atoms.com — skill bundle atoms. Repo: convergent-systems-co/skill-atoms (in-progress).

The atom registries are consumed by bin/ai via a single resolver implementation (only the URL template and content type differ between them). The contracts (atom metadata schema, content-hash verification, SemVer pinning) are defined in SPEC.md §7.9 and §7.10.

Definition of Done — v0.8

The v0.8 milestone is complete when:

1. SPEC.md is consistent, signed off, and matches the implementation surface this repo ships.
2. The Go CLI (ai) builds cleanly and exposes all verbs from SPEC.md §3 (stubs are acceptable for v0.8; the surface is the contract).
3. The hook library at hooks/ ships every hook named in SPEC.md §15, each runnable on stdlib python3 with a --self-check mode.
4. hooks/patterns.json is the single canonical secret pattern source, consumed by secret-block.py, secret-precommit.py, the pre-sync scan in bin/ai, and the redaction pass in ai issue file.
5. hooks/command-wrappers.toml ships the canonical wrapper config (git, gh, opt-in terraform/kubectl).
6. The .github/ISSUE_TEMPLATE/ directory contains the six Markdown templates from SPEC.md §9.5 and §14.3 (epic, feature, story, task, hook, finding).
7. The Astro site scaffold at web/ai-constitution/ builds and links to the spec.
8. The repo’s own CI does not use trufflehog (SPEC.md §10.4 forbids it).

Out of scope for v0.8 (morning work, deliberately deferred):

• Persona content (persona-atoms.com/agentic/*, persona-atoms.com/reviewer/*).
• Profile content (profile-atoms.com/*).
• JSON Schemas (settings.schema.json, profile.schema.json, skill-manifest.schema.json, atom-metadata.schema.json).
• Live atom-registry integration (HTTP fetch + cache).
• Live brand-atoms fetch in the Astro site.

These are tracked as TODO markers in code and in the relevant section of this repo. SPEC.md is the authoritative source on what they should become.